During CNN's September 4 coverage of the Republican National Convention, CNN contributor Bill
Bennett stated: "On the issues, the immigration debate, a lot of people thought would derail John
McCain. He hasn't recanted that position. He hasn't recanted his position on McCain-Feingold or
McCain-Kennedy." In fact, McCain stated during a Republican primary
debate that he
would not vote for the immigration reform bill he co-sponsored with Sen. Ted Kennedy (D-MA).
While McCain previously took the
position that border security could not be disaggregated from other aspects of comprehensive
immigration reform without being rendered ineffective, he has since reversed himself, now saying that "we've got to
secure the borders first."
Media Matters for America has repeatedly noted examples of the media falsely using immigration
reform as an example of McCain breaking with Republicans, without mentioning his reversal.
From CNN's September 4 coverage of the Republican National Convention:
BLITZER: You heard Carl Bernstein say, Bill, that the John McCain that we're going to see
tonight, that we've been seeing recently, is not the John McCain that so many reporters and
others knew over the years. You want to respond to that?
BENNETT: Yeah. I would like to, thanks. First, I think they need to get the message -- the
critics need to get the message clear. Is John McCain in a full embrace of the Republican
conservatives and George Bush, or all are they all mad and yelling at him like, you know, [Sen.]
Mitch McConnell [R-KY] and George Bush? Because I think probably John McCain has been yelled at
and had more temper tantrums with Republican leadership than anybody else. But on the issues, the
immigration debate, a lot of people thought would derail John McCain. He hasn't recanted that
position. He hasn't recanted his position on McCain-Feingold or McCain-Kennedy. John McCain's
last name, conservatives were saying, is causing a lot of trouble.
Remember Gary Bauer? Family Research [Council ex-president] and all of that. When he dropped out
of the 2000 race, who did he endorse? He endorsed John McCain. John McCain has been pro-life all
his life. He is not in favor of a constitutional amendment banning gay marriage. I think it's
been pretty consistent.
CAMPBELL BROWN (CNN anchor): Well, but he's refined his position on immigration during his --
during the campaign.
BENNETT: He's emphasized securing the borders.
BROWN: During -- building the wall first --
BLITZER: Marsha Blackburn is a congresswoman from Tennessee. Let's listen to her.
Recommandations
)
and reject those that you are not interested in
(
)
